How Islamic banks
manage in business without charging interest
?
In a previous article I presented
the argument that Islamic banking institutio ns were weathering the
present financial crisis comparatively well as they were, or
certainly should be, insulated from the disasters in the interbank
market and the mess in the derivatives markets as we have seen
recently on the complete collapsed of financial Market and that is
mainly greed, charging interest and lack of accountability and
transparency. A number of readers raised the logical question of how
Islamic banks manage to stay in business without charging interest.
To recap, one of the basic
principles of Islamic banking is the prohibition of usury or
interest. Up until the 1980s interest was generally interpreted to
only apply to usury but it is now accepted practice to refer to all
interest. Other principles are based on simple morality and common
sense, which are by no means unique to Islam. For example, usury was
also prohibited by the Old as well as the New Testament. Even
literary heavyweights such as Shakespeare weighed in against the
practice.
Islamic banking is also by no
means a recent phenomenon. The basic practices can be traced back to
the early parts of the seventh century. Some experts even claim that
many of the concepts and techniques so familiar to us today were
later adopted by European bankers. Its fairly recent reemergence
coincided with rising oil prices in the mid 1970s thus providing
parts of the Muslim world with significant financial resources. The
other crucial element was the accompanying search for ethical values
in managing their financial affairs, something many of the
traditionally western financial organizations could not provide. As
this is a trend not only applicable to the Muslim world, the
emerging Islamic banks are increasingly being accepted by
non-Muslims who do not wish to invest in, or even deposit their
savings with companies engaged in unethical and socially harmful
activities, such as dealing in alcohol, gambling, pornography and
tobacco.
The Islamic economic system is
concerned with social justice to ensure that none of the parties
involved in a transaction is being exploited without at the same
time inhibiting individual enterprise. Extended to the Islamic
financial system, this means that the funds individuals and/or
companies put at risk share the profits or losses resulting from the
enterprise. This concept of sharing the delights or pain of the
outcome of business is a progressive one. It is not the strongest
financial system that survives, nor the most intelligent. It is the
one that is most adaptable to change. Islamic banking encourages
better resources management, in particular as outright speculation
is not permitted by Islamic law. The participants are keeping pace
with sophisticated techniques and have developed products that are
not only ethically motivated but also profitable.The basic principle
of Islamic banking follows the Islamic rules on transaction. The
term "Islamic banking" is synonymous with "full-reserve banking" and
"Islamic Law-compliant banking." The most prominent feature of these
laws is usury – the prohibition of paying or collecting interest on
funds. The Islamic Law also forbids engagement in investments that
include financial unknowns such as buying and selling futures, as
well as businesses that are forbidden – dealing in products that are
contrary to Islamic law and values such as alcohol, pork, gossip or
pornography. These principles apply to all individuals, companies
and governments.
Banks that comply with Islamic law are forbidden to charge interest
or late payment fees, which is also considered a type of interest.
To minimize risk, banks will often require a large down payment on
goods and property, or insist upon large collateral.
Banks that comply with Islamic law are forbidden to charge interest
or late payment fees, which is also considered a type of interest.
To minimize risk, banks will often require a large down payment on
goods and property, or insist upon large collateral. It is lawful
for the Bank to charge a higher price for a good if payments are
deferred or collected at a later date since it is considered a trade
for goods rather than collecting interest. Islamic Law-compliant
banking products include(profit sharing),(safekeeping),(joint
venture),(cost plus) and(leasing). Another way that banks work
within Islamic laws while trying to turn a profit is by buying an
item that the customer wants, and then selling the item to the
customer at a higher price.
The profit sharing is a partnership between an entrepreneur and the
bank. The bank is known as the asset owner and the entrepreneur as
the profit-sharing. The bank provides all of the necessary capital
to start a business and the entrepreneur does the work of managing
the business. Profits are split at an agreed ratio until the initial
funds of the asset-owner are paid off. The asset-owner is also
compensated with additional funds based on the profits of the
business in terms previously agreed on. In the event that the
business folds, the asset-owner shoulders the cost and the
profit-sharing is not compensated.
Joint venture is similar to profit sharing, in which an entrepreneur
seeks funds for a business venture and pays the bank back with a
ratio of profits. However, there are often more than two parties who
contribute funds and become partners who can influence the business
depending on the amount of money invested. The entrepreneur also
contributes funds and shares in the risk. Any loss is proportional
to the amount of capital invested in the business.
Safe-keeping is a system in which a person deposits money into a
bank and receives a "gift" from the bank. The bank is the keeper of
the funds and will refund the entire amount at the demand of the
depositor. The bank rewards the amount of time the depositor keeps
the money in the bank with a gift, which is not guaranteed. The gift
is similar to interest, but lawful according the Islamic law.
Cost-plus governs the issuing of home loans or any other type of
goods needed by a borrower. An Islamic bank does not lend money to a
borrower to buy properties; rather, the bank will purchase the
property at the borrower’s request at a freely disclosed price, and
mark up the price for the borrower to pay back, therefore making a
profit from the investment. The borrower is named on the title and
allowed to utilize the property immediately and pays the bank back
in installments.
Another type of loan is the leasing, in which the bank buys the home
or item and leases the property to the borrower while retaining
ownership of the property. The borrower can either use the property
for a pre-determined period of time, or pay off the purchase price
and buy out the Bank to attain full ownership of the property.
There are occasionally controversies surrounding the interpretation
of the interest, which certain scholars argue was meant to prevent
petty money-lenders from abusing borrowers, rather than a modern
bank charging a reasonable, agreed upon interest. The general
consensus, however, is that any interest is a direct violation of
the law of Sharia and therefore unethical.
In conclusion, Islamic financial solutions generally have Arabic
names thus intimidating many potential buyers into saying it is all
too complicated. At their core, most of these products are
essentially the same as their conventional equivalents. The main
differences are the absence of interest and often complicated
procedures to ensure compliance with Islamic law. Also,should the
borrower default on a rental or principal repayment, the bank may
advance the borrower an interest-free loan to enable him to continue
their payments in anticipation that he will pay in full when he is
able to. The good news is that during this period of distress, the
borrower retains his home rather than face eviction. Having said
this, Islamic banks still appraise credit risk, and indeed are more
cautious about who they finance than conventional banks.
The Western countries are now looking into how the Islamic banking
System will be introduced in their countries, such as Britain who
already implemented an Islamic banks and others. This will help many
Muslim immigrants who up to this moment doesn't have any banking
alternatives other than using Interest ccommercial banks which is
against their Islamic religion principles of not using usury or
interest.
Dr. Shacabi
California, USA
email:
shacabi@yahoo.com
|